EduDebate
Who Should Solve the Skills Gap?

Mind the gap: all over the world, graduates struggle to find work yet millions of jobs are waiting to be filled. In face of this pervasive disconnect between job supply and job demand, business owners blame schools for not adapting what students are taught to the labor market’s needs, while school leaders complain that employers are not taking their share of responsibility by developing effective training programs.
  
How can different stakeholders work together and innovate to fix the mismatches between worker skills and employer needs and create a workforce of lifelong learners? Experts share their views. 


Participants
Peter Cappelli
Monica Flores
Sébastien Turbot

Filling the Right Gaps with the Right People

Mr. Austin X. Volz
Program Director, Avenues Beijing
Oct 26, 2015
Filling the Right Gaps with the Right People
The Gap(s)

For all the recent discussion around the skills gap, the numerous reports indicate that there are gaps, not a gap. A broad survey of the research divides skill gaps into two broad areas: the lack of technical skills, and the lack of transferable or 'soft' skills. 

On the technical skills plane, economists such as Levy and Murnane and David Autor identify the importance of non-routine expert thinking as routine skills become increasingly automated. The 2013 Careerbuilder talent gap report cites computer and mathematical positions as the most difficult to fill. And the ManpowerGroup 2015 report lists Sales Representative, Technician, and Engineer as among the most difficult positions to fill internationally. An employer survey by the UK Commission on Education and Skills reports that 64% of employers found the technical skills of employees lacking.

On the transferable skills plane, a 2014 Lumina Foundation and The Economist Intelligence Unit report focusing on U.S. industry finds that employers identify skills such as critical thinking and collaboration more important than technical skills associated with a job. Similarly, survey of U.S. executives by Adecco, a human resource consulting company, reports that 44% of executives believe new hires lack soft skills like communication and creativity. And, the same survey cited above by the UK Commission on Education and Skills reports that 41% of employers found communication skills lacking.

That both transferable and technical skills emerge as part of the skills gap is perhaps to be expected. After all, one of the main sources of the gap is how quickly jobs are changing. Even if it were possible to magically grant the requisite number of employees the necessary technical skills, those same technical skills may be obsolete in 5 years. Any solution to the skills gap thus needs to address both transferable and technical skills and, perhaps obviously, also needs to be able to develop along with the quickly changing skill demands. 

Vocational and Cultural Education

In some countries, the solution to the need for transferable skills need has given rise to an increase of postsecondary liberal arts and science education. Examples include Xinya College and Fudan College in China, Amsterdam University College in the Netherlands, O.P. Jindal Global University in India, Yale-NUS in Singapore and numerous others. Indeed, in the U.S. liberal arts and science education routinely invokes its ability to foster transferable skills.

But that solution may not be broadly accessible and may still leave out some technical skills. Traditionally, a vocational school and a liberal arts college seem irreconcilable: one centered on practical access and the other centered on elite cultural education. However, if instead of social hierarchy we think rather in terms of the learning outcomes liberal arts education proposes to impart, then a solution to the skills gap emerges. Research on the effects of liberal arts colleges on students’ critical thinking abilities found that gains were almost entirely mediated by instructional practices. Specifically, learning experiences that challenged students to weigh the strengths and weaknesses of their arguments and to look at an issue from a different perspective were most correlated with gains in critical thinking. In short: transferable skills are born more through method than content.

Read full article

Improving pedagogy helps solve the transferable skill gap. To develop a long-term solution for technical skills it is necessary to avoid overspecialization. A study comparing the employment rates of those who received vocational or general education across 18 countries found that those who received general education were more likely to experience a steady increase in employability that ultimately eliminated the initial employability advantage of specialization. The trade-off was particularly pronounced in countries with established apprenticeship programs such as Denmark, Germany, and Sweden. As various specialized skills become obsolete, having a broad foundation enables one to learn new technical skills more quickly. 

To solve the skills gap, it’s time to merge vocational and cultural education.

So who should solve the skill gap? Who should take the job? To find those with the skills, a job description may prove useful. 

Job Description

The job has three parts: identify the technical skills in demand, design instruction that incorporates reflective learning, and teach.

Employers are best equipped to identify and assess the necessary technical skills. They have much to gain and they know the landscape of their industries the best. 

Educators are necessary to incorporate pedagogies that foster transferable skills such as reflective learning activities (the research above is only one example how this could be done). Providing students with practice in evaluating the strengths of various arguments could involve a debate on worker conditions that are part of a supply chain; in technology fields, it could entail discussing the argument of Kevin Kelly’s, founding executive editor of Wired magazine, that technology has its own inherent biases; healthcare services could evaluate the economic, social, and cultural sources of healthcare access disparities. Critical thinking doesn’t require Plato and Shakespeare. 

Those teaching could be drawn either from industry professionals, from professional educators, or from both. Since the required talent for this new job could come from any of these groups, there is no reason to uphold existing boundaries between education and industry. 

Hard to Find

The job description makes it clear that to solve the skills gap by merging vocational and cultural education collaboration is essential. We should remember that the survey results above identify collaboration and communication as the very skills that form the gap. But in this case the search isn’t for a single employee. For just as there are skills gaps more than a single gap, similarly we don’t need to find the one who will do the job of solving the gap, but the ones.

The views expressed by Austin are his own and do not represent Avenues. 

Themes
Employment and Skills Gap, Higher Education, Curriculum Design and Ecosystem

Join the Discussion

249 comments
Isaenyaoneno's picture
Isaenyaoneno
cialis daily price [url=http://cialisuperfd.com/]buy cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisuperfd.com/">generic cialis online</a> cialis canada buy for sale
reply - Dec 05, 2017
Witalinaoneno's picture
Witalinaoneno
viagra zollfrei kaufen [url=http://viagraoqh.com/]online viagra[/url] <a href="http://viagraoqh.com/">generic viagra online</a> daily viagra coupon
reply - Nov 29, 2017
Ewaoneno's picture
Ewaoneno
cialis soft buy [url=http://cialistas.com/]cialis online[/url] <a href="http://cialistas.com/">cheap cialis</a> cialis canadian pharmacy
reply - Nov 29, 2017
Klimenyukoneno's picture
Klimenyukoneno
att bestalla viagra [url=http://viagrafzld.com/]buy viagra[/url] <a href="http://viagrafzld.com/">generic viagra online</a> only now how viagra works
reply - Nov 29, 2017
Witaoneno's picture
Witaoneno
viagra rezeptfrei legal [url=http://viagrapillskj.com/]cheap viagra[/url] <a href="http://viagrapillskj.com/">online viagra</a> we recommend original viagra
reply - Nov 24, 2017
Alfredoneno's picture
Alfredoneno
follow link cialis rx website [url=http://cialisorderas.com/]order cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisorderas.com/">generic cialis</a> effects side cialis term men
reply - Nov 24, 2017
Snezhanaoneno's picture
Snezhanaoneno
can buy viagra auckland [url=http://buyviagralkq.com/]buy viagra[/url] <a href="http://buyviagralkq.com/">cheap viagra</a> buy generic viagra buy
reply - Nov 22, 2017
Gaponovaoneno's picture
Gaponovaoneno
cialis 20 mg dure [url=http://cialisonlinehaq.com/]cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisonlinehaq.com/">cialis online</a> next day real cialis
reply - Nov 19, 2017
Pletnewoneno's picture
Pletnewoneno
viagra online secure tabs [url=http://viagraonlinefas.com/]buy viagra online[/url] <a href="http://viagraonlinefas.com/">buy generic viagra</a> viagra con receta en farmacias
reply - Nov 13, 2017
Sokowaoneno's picture
Sokowaoneno
only today low cost viagra uk <a href=http://viagragenericvas.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://viagragenericvas.com/">online viagra</a> le levitra viagra suisse
reply - Nov 11, 2017
Wadimoneno's picture
Wadimoneno
viagra kamagra gu http://viagralkp.com/ - viagra online <a href="http://viagralkp.com/">viagra online</a> viagra 4 100
reply - Nov 11, 2017
Osmininaoneno's picture
Osmininaoneno
comprare viagra in thailandia <a href=http://viagrahsk.com/>buy viagra online</a> <a href="http://viagrahsk.com/">buy viagra online</a> viagra tablets sale uk
reply - Nov 08, 2017
Osmininaoneno's picture
Osmininaoneno
viagra indio generico <a href=http://viagrahsk.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://viagrahsk.com/">viagra cheap</a> viagra billig lastschrift
reply - Nov 08, 2017
Vidmanoneno's picture
Vidmanoneno
indications for use of cialis <a href=http://cialisknz.com/>cialis canada</a> <a href="http://cialisknz.com/">generic cialis</a> buy cialis 5 mg from india
reply - Oct 26, 2017
Tomaoneno's picture
Tomaoneno
approved viagra ® store http://viagrakjs.com/ - viagra online <a href="http://viagrakjs.com/">generic viagra</a> viagra autentica espan
reply - Oct 25, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
cialis 10 mg comprimes filme <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">cialis cheap</a> generic cialis super active
reply - Oct 16, 2017
Gerhaoneno's picture
Gerhaoneno
follow link cialis low priced <a href=http://buycheapkcialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://buycheapkcialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> we recommend 2.5mg cialis
reply - Oct 08, 2017
Gerhaoneno's picture
Gerhaoneno
quel est le prix du cialis <a href=http://buycheapkcialis.com/>buy cheap cialis</a> <a href="http://buycheapkcialis.com/">buy cheap cialis</a> cialis oder so
reply - Oct 08, 2017
Gerhaoneno's picture
Gerhaoneno
generic cialis pics <a href=http://buycheapkcialis.com/>buy cheap cialis</a> <a href="http://buycheapkcialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> canadian pharmacy cialis soft
reply - Oct 07, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
bestel viagra <a href=http://cheapviagraik.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://cheapviagraik.com/">viagra online</a> enter site viagra side effect
reply - Oct 07, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
recommended site cialis pill <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>buy cialis online</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">canadian cialis</a> qual o nome generico do cialis
reply - Oct 07, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
buy viagra now resource <a href=http://cheapviagraik.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://cheapviagraik.com/">viagra generic</a> try it viagra online online
reply - Oct 07, 2017
Gerhaoneno's picture
Gerhaoneno
tarif cialis pharmacie <a href=http://buycheapkcialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://buycheapkcialis.com/">buy cheap cialis</a> can cialis cause afib
reply - Oct 07, 2017
Nerkooneno's picture
Nerkooneno
viagra female pink <a href=http://viagragenericsj.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://viagragenericsj.com/">buy viagra</a> viagra different doses
reply - Oct 05, 2017
Gerfdoneno's picture
Gerfdoneno
brand name viagra <a href=http://viagracheappbgs.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://viagracheappbgs.com/">viagra</a> viagra bild tablette
reply - Oct 05, 2017
Gerfdoneno's picture
Gerfdoneno
watch viagra falls online free <a href=http://viagracheappbgs.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://viagracheappbgs.com/">viagra generic</a> effetti viagra erezione
reply - Oct 04, 2017
Volopsaoneno's picture
Volopsaoneno
cialis 20 mg controindicazioni <a href=http://cheapgenericialisjh.com/>generic cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgenericialisjh.com/">generic cialis online</a> compare prices cialis 20mg
reply - Oct 03, 2017
Voldemoneno's picture
Voldemoneno
il cialis acquisto su linea <a href=http://buycialishgonline.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://buycialishgonline.com/">cialis</a> cialis soft tabs side effects
reply - Oct 02, 2017
Voldemoneno's picture
Voldemoneno
buy cialis discount pharmacy <a href=http://buycialishgonline.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://buycialishgonline.com/">cialis online</a> comprar cialis 5mg online.
reply - Oct 02, 2017
Verneoneno's picture
Verneoneno
le viagra generiqu http://canadianviagrats.com/ - cheap viagra <a href="http://canadianviagrats.com/">cheap viagra</a> viagra rezep
reply - Oct 02, 2017
Voldemoneno's picture
Voldemoneno
typical dosage of cialis <a href=http://buycialishgonline.com/>cialis</a> <a href="http://buycialishgonline.com/">cialis online</a> mail order cialis pills
reply - Oct 01, 2017
Verneoneno's picture
Verneoneno
online pfizer viagra verkauf http://canadianviagrats.com/ - discount viagra <a href="http://canadianviagrats.com/">discount viagra</a> hair salon black belt viagra
reply - Sep 30, 2017
Verneoneno's picture
Verneoneno
viagra achat en ligne canada http://canadianviagrats.com/ - cheap viagra <a href="http://canadianviagrats.com/">buy viagra</a> schweiz viagra cialis levitra
reply - Sep 30, 2017
Bailooneno's picture
Bailooneno
generico cialis peru http://cialischeapoks.com/ - cheap cialis <a href="http://cialischeapoks.com/">cheap cialis online</a> cialis kohlpharma
reply - Sep 29, 2017
Bailooneno's picture
Bailooneno
generique cialis en france http://cialischeapoks.com/ - cheap cialis online <a href="http://cialischeapoks.com/">generic cialis</a> cialis tadalafil pour la vente
reply - Sep 29, 2017
Bailooneno's picture
Bailooneno
cialis slovenia http://cialischeapoks.com/ - cialis online <a href="http://cialischeapoks.com/">cialis online</a> just try! cialis online sales
reply - Sep 28, 2017
Revebaoneno's picture
Revebaoneno
can u buy viagra walgreens <a href=http://cheaphgviagra.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://cheaphgviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> viagra in croatia
reply - Sep 28, 2017
Austrioneno's picture
Austrioneno
we choice cialis alternatives <a href=http://cialisjhgeneric.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cialisjhgeneric.com/">buy cialis online</a> cialis 10 mg dosis
reply - Sep 28, 2017
Bailooneno's picture
Bailooneno
good choice cialis order <a href=http://cialischeapoks.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://cialischeapoks.com/">cialis</a> cialis once a day generico
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Revebaoneno's picture
Revebaoneno
efectos viagra jovenes <a href=http://cheaphgviagra.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://cheaphgviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> viagra samples in australia
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Bailooneno's picture
Bailooneno
la valeur de cialis <a href=http://cialischeapoks.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cialischeapoks.com/">buy cialis online</a> cialis kaufen legal
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Austrioneno's picture
Austrioneno
proper dose for cialis <a href=http://cialisjhgeneric.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cialisjhgeneric.com/">generic cialis</a> tout sur cialis20
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Gelesoneno's picture
Gelesoneno
cialis doses recommended <a href=http://cheapjicialis.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapjicialis.com/">cialis coupon</a> codice sconto medstore cialis
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Gelesoneno's picture
Gelesoneno
cialis precio 10 mg <a href=http://cheapjicialis.com/>cialis coupon</a> <a href="http://cheapjicialis.com/">cialis coupon</a> non generic cialis online
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Vomironeno's picture
Vomironeno
cheap online meds viagra http://viagrabuygenzx.com/ - viagra <a href="http://viagrabuygenzx.com/">buy viagra</a> only for you viagra mexico
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Vomironeno's picture
Vomironeno
wow look it rx viagra <a href=http://viagrabuygenzx.com/>cheap viagra</a> <a href="http://viagrabuygenzx.com/">cheap viagra</a> viagra prezzo piu basso
reply - Sep 26, 2017
Vomironeno's picture
Vomironeno
marque viagra para la venta http://viagrabuygenzx.com/ - viagra online <a href="http://viagrabuygenzx.com/">order viagra</a> viagra 100 mg 4 comprimes
reply - Sep 26, 2017
Vomironeno's picture
Vomironeno
canihelp viagra <a href=http://viagrabuygenzx.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://viagrabuygenzx.com/">buy cheap viagra</a> viagra pfizer verkauf
reply - Sep 26, 2017
Vomironeno's picture
Vomironeno
achat viagra securis a <a href=http://viagrabuygenzx.com/>order viagra</a> <a href="http://viagrabuygenzx.com/">viagra generic</a> viagra for sale inside canada
reply - Sep 26, 2017
Goloaoneno's picture
Goloaoneno
cialis 20mg pas che <a href=http://canadianfdcialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://canadianfdcialis.com/">buy cialis</a> cialis super active m
reply - Sep 26, 2017

Pages

X