EduDebate
What Alternatives to Standardized Testing?

Standardized testing is still considered the most effective way of holding schools and systems accountable. However, these tests often fail to measure many learners' skills and creativity. 

In this EduDebate, education experts examine different assessment approaches that can strengthen student motivation, improve learning outcomes and encourage more creative teaching and learning, without jeopardizing accountability.

Participants
WISE ed.review: Guy Claxton
WISE EduDebate: A Call for Diverse Multiple Micro-Assessment Systems

Testing Reimagined: How and When Should Competency Be Assessed?

Ms Julia Freeland Fisher
Director of Education Research, Clayton Christensen Institute
Oct 06, 2014
WISE EduDebate: Testing Reimagined: How and When we Should Be Assessing Competency
We can all remember the cycle of emotions involved in taking tests: trying to cram as much into our heads, sitting the test, and eventually receiving a grade, weeks later, already immersed in new subject matter. Our grades may have clearly communicated what we knew on the day of that test. But opportunities to go back and learn what we’d missed rarely presented themselves. 

Competency-based education presents an alternative philosophy of when and on what terms students take tests and move on to new material. In competency-based models, students advance upon mastery. A different spirit of assessment sits at the fulcrum of competency-based approaches: students only move on to new or more challenging material once they can show that they’ve mastered more basic skills and concepts. This means that students will often advance at different paces, and sometimes along different pathways. This also means that a competency-based system requires paradigm shifts in both how and when we assess students’ mastery. 
 

How are students assessed for mastery?

Competency-based high schools in the U.S. use a variety of modalities to assess students. A number of these approaches are being used in the state of New Hampshire, in the United States, which has mandated that all high schools measure credit in terms of competency rather than time. Some schools like Sanborn Regional High School still use many traditional pen-and-paper exams, but with one key difference: they offer “reassessment without penalty” for students scoring below 80 percent. Therefore students do not fail, but rather revisit material until they are able to retake tests to demonstrate mastery.  

Other competency-based schools, particularly those using blended learning curricula such as North Country Charter Academy, rely heavily on online assessment. In such schools, students engage primarily in self-paced online curriculum and receive face-to-face support from teachers on an as-needed basis. As such, the school relies heavily on online assessments to gauge gaps in students’ understanding and determine when individual students are ready to move on to the next online lesson or module. 

Still other competency-based models, like Next Charter School, assess mastery through student projects rather than on pen-and-paper or online tests at the end of a lesson or unit. For example, the students in a social studies course might be asked to write a letter to President Obama proposing foreign policy strategies. The letter might have to include both a historical account of previous foreign policy strategies, a proposed action, and a rationale and justification for why that proposed action was the best option. To assess these projects in a competency-based rather than a time-based manner, the school adds in additional supports and opportunities to revisit material. Leading up to final projects like this one, teachers use various formative assessments, like short quizzes or less formal inquiry, to gauge students’ progress toward mastering various competencies and readiness for their final project. This helps to ensure that students are not assessed until they appear ready, rather than on a fixed schedule regardless of their mastery or lack thereof. Additionally, if a student fails to demonstrate mastery in his final project, he has the option to revise his final project, or he can move on and design a new project to address the competency or competencies that he failed to master. 

As schools design systems and processes to assess mastery and growth on an ongoing basis, they are also increasingly incorporating performance assessments in their curricula. Performance assessments are tests that aim to assess students’ abilities to demonstrate competencies across various disciplines and focus on the “application” of competencies, rather than on the rote memorization of facts. For example, a student may be able to answer multiple-choice math questions, but a performance assessment would test his ability to calculate change in dollars and cents in a sales transaction. 

Some schools like Sanborn are designing performance tasks that can be administered through traditional pen-and-paper exams, but test concepts in the context of real-world examples. Other schools have incorporated performance-based assessment into projects, such as the letter to the President described above, through which students are expected to apply their understanding of U.S. history and foreign policy to a real-world persuasive writing task. At still other schools, such as MC2, students are expected to ultimately defend their learning in front of a panel of teachers, much like doctoral students are expected to defend their dissertations in front of a committee of scholars. 

 

When are students being assessed?

 Shifting assessments to create a competency-based model not only requires new modes of testing student mastery, but also more flexible, on-demand opportunities for students to take tests. Without fundamentally shifting its assessment schedule to allow students to take assessments when they are ready, and providing opportunities for students to revisit material that they have not mastered, schools cannot pursue a truly competency-based model.

On-demand assessment is challenging because it contradicts schools’ traditional approaches to verifying student learning on a fixed academic calendar. Schools must reconceive their calendar and schedule in a far more individualized light if they are to imagine assessing students when students are ready to be assessed, rather than on a fixed day, at a fixed time. Some smaller schools may manage to assess students on this as-needed basis. But to scale such a system likely requires the adoption of new technology platforms. These platforms will need to track student progress, help to calculate when students are ready to be assessed, and in some cases provide appropriate assessment items on-demand. Without such capabilities, tracking each student’s progress and appropriate assessment schedule would prove overwhelming to any one educator.

Government accountability systems, such as annual exams, likewise pose obstacles to creating on-demand assessment systems. To ultimately square top-down accountability regimes with ambitions for more personalized learning systems, these national or state tests will likely need to be administered on a more flexible schedule.

For a complete look at how 13 schools are transitioning to competency-based learning in New Hampshire, United States, see: From policy to practice: How competency-based education is evolving in New Hampshire

Themes
Assessment, Learning (Blended, Personalized, Formal, Informal)

Join the Discussion

340 comments
Snezhanaoneno's picture
Snezhanaoneno
current price viagra india [url=http://buyviagralkq.com/]buy generic viagra[/url] <a href="http://buyviagralkq.com/">online viagra</a> viagra scaduto risch
reply - Nov 21, 2017
Scott Jones's picture
Scott Jones
In case you are http://www.nike-uptempo.com/ not able to purchase the primary LV bags, choose the good quality replicate items which are additionally the splendid fashion accessories to reduce females right up.<br /> <br /> Aside by retaining these people, a number of well-known famous http://www.coachoutletfactorys.us.com/ people get given the people to promoting's collection. The majority of only recently http://www.michaelkorsoutletonline-official.us.com/ , Madonna, Uma Thurman, Scarlett Johansson, in addition to Sean Connery have http://www.katespadeoutlet-online.us/ in fact shown up with Handbags marketing and advertising tasks, fortifying the web link amongst this brandname as well as the Showmanship way of living.<br /> <br /> On a person level I am just trying http://www.katespadeoutletfactory.us.com/ to keep the expectation way up in which we http://www.kyrieirving-shoes.com/ shall visit a authentic Cell phone Excursion easily. Nice and dark and well.....Blackberry-ish. Could be doning with gold and silver.<br /> <br /> The Gratitude Collection's Graffiti Keepall can be purchased in brilliant Day-Glo colorings http://www.ultraboost.org/ offering the stylish duffle some sort of happiness connected with route stylish. Keepall supplies a http://www.lebron-15.us/ vast beginning that means it is particularly person enjoyable as it is simple to set items to send and receive. The particular bag includes pure cowhide extras in http://www.yeezy350v2boost.us/ addition to spherical manages attracted focus on by simply silver metal equipment http://www.nikeairmax2018.us/ , it provides a double squat closing, is usually maintained manually , as well as includes a detachable synthetic leather suitcases draw http://www.pandorajewelryofficialsite.com/ which might be hotstamped with just about any shops which offers the service.<br /> <br /> As an outcome on the brand-new guidelines, Italy's challenging accessibility, Prada Luna Rossa, possesses vulnerable not to ethnic background http://www.eccoshoes.org.uk/ until finally their own resentments usually are listened tightly to be able to and adjudicated.<br /> <br /> http://www.pandora-outlets.us/ The things that pay one of a kind target composition? handwork as well as variety stops, such as garments, are searhing for for http://www.longchampoutletsale.us.com/ reliability. Nevertheless, those things along with fairly reduced rate, for instance parfum along http://www.ralphlaurenoutletonline-store.us.com/ with fittings, frequently increase the risk for top gain and therefore are the greatest cash flow way to obtain these types of luxurious goods companies.<br /> <br /> A consumer locating to get a http://www.coachoutlet-official.us.com/ traditional LV Vuitton items must get home elevators LV as well as fresh assortment; http://www.yeezyboost350v2stores.us.com/ making sure that, if a supplier offers a bag which includes definitely not also been per stores but or the expecting detailing is upon; then you must avoid http://www.clarks-shoes.org/ through acquiring these solution. For http://www.ralphlaurensaleuk.org.uk/ just a assortment that may be fresh store; any sort of supplier boasting for you to supply these series of their look is perhaps giving fake.<br /> <br /> Besides the actual indeniable http://www.underarmour-outlet.us/ performances of the Neverfull, each of our favored valuable perform may be the http://www.jordan11space-jam.us/ modifiable area band which come criterion with all different versions. Through an effortless adjust on the band, it is simple to customize the particular http://www.nike-vapormax.us.com/ size with the usable interior space. Whether you're vacationing gentle or maybe wrapping in every single little point however the kitchen's sink, you'll constantly have recently http://www.pandora--jewelry.us.com/ the right amount associated with bedroom.
reply - Oct 22, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
cheap cialis fast in toronto <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">cialis canada</a> where do i get cialis
reply - Oct 15, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
compra cialis 5mg <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>canadian cialis</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">cialis cheap</a> compre muestras de cialis
reply - Oct 14, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
cialis super active next day <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">buy cialis online</a> precio cialis mejor generico
reply - Oct 12, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
venta cialis domicilio <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> buy cialis 36 hour
reply - Oct 11, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
only today cialis cheap price <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis</a> can i take 2 5mg cialis
reply - Oct 11, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis levitra comparaison <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis online</a> buy cialis seattle online
reply - Oct 11, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis online da europa <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> cialis mezza pasticca
reply - Oct 11, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
qual a dose ideal de cialis <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis online</a> generic pharmacy cialis
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis generique du r-u <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis cheap</a> just try! 50 mg cialis
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cipla cialis review <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>generic cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">buy cialis</a> generic pharmacy cialis
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis price 20 <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> generic cialis pills
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis free trial nz <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> cialis 36 or
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis e spor <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">buy cialis</a> cialis canadian source
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis generica deutschland <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis online</a> generic cialis research
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cheapest online cialis pills <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis</a> cialis otc
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
lowest price cialis 20mg <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis cheap</a> cialis pills email
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
price for cialis pills <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">buy cialis</a> free trial cialis voucher
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
sex pills viagra and levitra <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> buy in new where i can viagra
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis farmacia svizzera <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>buy cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis online</a> cialis comentarios
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
get prescription for cialis <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">buy cialis online</a> cialis vendita farmaci
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
commande viagra ligne <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>order viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra online</a> viagra patents
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
buy in new where i can viagra <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">order viagra</a> viagra rezeptpflichtig holland
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
online pharmacy real viagra. <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>buy cheap viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra online</a> viagra for men canada
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis vs generic cialis <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis online</a> cialis sur ordonnance
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
pfizer viagra espana <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra</a> what is the use for viagra
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
sconto in linea cialis <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> generic for cialis
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
google online viagra sales <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra online</a> viagra fur die frau
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
viagra achat quebec <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>buy cheap viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">order viagra</a> buy in new where i can viagra
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
salon black belt viagra <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra online</a> generic viagra canada news
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
to order cialis online <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">buy cialis</a> cialis original gunstig kaufe
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
from mail order viagra by <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> viagra patents
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
viagra professional without rx <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> viagra generico da ems
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
enter site best cialis prices <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> cialis printable free
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
where to buy viagra in morocco <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra online</a> freie viagra proben von pfizer
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
retail pharmacy price cialis <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> cialis farmacia svizzera
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
viagra send <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>order viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">order viagra</a> i recommend viagra uk shop
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
cialis viagra efficacite <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>cheap viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">buy cheap viagra</a> viagra canada drug
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis sales online usa <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>generic cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">cialis online</a> tomar cialis ocasionalment
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
vioxx viagra <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra generic</a> generisches viagra paypal
reply - Oct 10, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis original gunstig kaufe <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">buy cialis</a> 2 5 mg cialis generic
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
viagra online china to china <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>buy cheap viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">buy viagra</a> look there viagra mail order
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
buying viagra in toronto <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra online</a> buying viagra samples online
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
cheap viagra in uk paypal <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">buy cheap viagra</a> viagra flashback
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Getrudaoneno's picture
Getrudaoneno
cialis 5 mg ou 10 mg <a href=http://cheapgfccialis.com/>buy cialis online</a> <a href="http://cheapgfccialis.com/">buy cialis online</a> cialis et hypertensio
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
viagra generico on lin <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> price of viagra at wallmart
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
cheap viagra next day delivery <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> free pack mail viagra by
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
cheapest viagra prices online <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>order viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">viagra</a> marcas de genericos de viagra
reply - Oct 09, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
viagra online china to china <a href=http://canadiangfviagra.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://canadiangfviagra.com/">cheap viagra</a> super viagra buy
reply - Oct 09, 2017

Pages

X