Should Teaching “Soft” Skills Be a Priority?

Paul Tough: Should Teaching “Soft” Skills Be a Priority?
An interview with Paul Tough, author of How Children Succeed: Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of Character (Random House)

As someone who analyzes data on student achievement in Latin America for a living, I have always been skeptical of calls for schools to teach so-called “non-cognitive” skills. Learning outcomes in the region are abysmally low. Two thirds of 15-year-olds in Argentina perform at the lowest levels of international assessments of math. Low-income students in Chile lag behind their wealthy peers by more than two grades. Even Brazil, the country that has made the most progress over the past decade, is projected to take at least 27 years to reach the average math performance of developed nations. 

Why would a region that allows young people to graduate from high school without basic arithmetic and reading comprehension skills set out to do more? And why would we think that it could? Sure, it would be nice if, in going about their daily business, schools instilled skills like perseverance, curiosity, conscientiousness, optimism, and self-control. But should they make it a priority? If resources are scarce, and if more time invested in something means less time invested in something else, asking schools to teach character may not only be hopeless, but also harmful.

Two weeks ago, I had the privilege of sitting down with Paul Tough, an acclaimed education journalist who writes often for the New York Times, after he gave the keynote speech at the World Innovation Summit for Education in Doha, Qatar. Tough is not an education scholar, but that has worked in his favor. He possesses a unique gift that eludes many academics for anticipating pressing questions in the field, distilling the key lessons from rigorous research, and identifying promising initiatives. The initial chapters of his first book, Whatever It Takes (2008), offer perhaps the most compelling non-technical discussion of what we know about how to educate low-income minority students.

Tough’s latest book, How Children Succeed (2012), makes an unapologetic case for teaching non-cognitive skills at school. It argues that these skills are not a substitute, but a complement to cognitive skills. Children, Tough argues, under-perform in school partly because they have a hard time doing seemingly simple things like staying focused while reading a long passage or not giving up when trying to solve a complicated equation. Cultivating self-control and perseverance, Tough argues, is not just “nice”. It enables children to do well in subjects like math and reading. 

As any other Latin American (worse yet, an Argentine), I hate being proven wrong. But after finishing Tough’s book (which I did in just one sitting, thanks to his “The New Yorker-meets-The Economist” writing style), I was a happy convert. The volume introduced me to decades’ worth of research in psychology and economics showing that character strengths at early ages predict later success, and perhaps most importantly, that simple interventions can go a long way in improving these skills.

In spite of Tough’s successful proselytization, I had a few questions. First on my list was whether schools should be in the business of teaching non-cognitive skills at all, or whether this is best left to parents. Although they are often called “skills”, things like self-control, grit, or self-esteem can also be thought of as (teachable) personality traits. Are schools overstepping their boundaries by seeking to shape students’ character? 

For Tough, this is one of those questions that we education researchers love to mull over, but that parents themselves find a non-issue. “Every parent is desperate for advice. As a parent myself, I can tell you that no one has it all figured out,” says Tough. Indeed, he argues, even affluent parents stand to benefit from character education. In How Children Succeed, he tells the story of how Dominic Randolph, the headmaster of a prestigious private school in New York City, worries that by single-mindedly rewarding success, well-off parents may be inadvertently sheltering children from valuable frustrating experiences that can teach them how to confront challenging situations later in life.

Even if teaching character at school is necessary, I wondered whether it was possible. Many of the initiatives Tough describes in his latest book take place in schools that have already figured out how to get all students to excel in academic subjects. Could public schools in Latin America do the same? Tough certainly thinks so: “For many teachers, teaching non-cognitive skills is intuitive. They know these skills are important, and they’re inclined to want to teach them.” 

For Tough, teaching character is about unleashing the potential of teachers and parents to share with children why it is important to do things like resisting distractions or setting clear goals, and to give students feedback about how they can get better at these habits. In his book, Tough tells the story of Elizabeth Spiegel, a chess teacher in a school serving low-income minority students in Brooklyn. When her students lose a game, she sits down with them and replays every single move, calling them on each of their mistakes.

Tough admits this is not what happens in most classrooms. “Math teachers don’t think of themselves in the same way, but that does not mean that they shouldn’t.” In math, like in chess, “students should be allowed to struggle with hard problems. And teachers should play more of a coaching role: telling students what they did wrong and how they can do it better,” claims Tough.

Teaching character may be desirable, and it may even be possible inside the classroom, but is it up to each teacher, or is there something schools can do to help parents and teachers? In his book, Tough describes the “character report card” used at the Knowledge Is Power Program (KIPP) charter schools in the United States. These report cards ask teachers to rate students on seven “strengths”: zest, grit, optimism, self-control, gratitude, social intelligence, and curiosity. The report card is based on the research of two leading psychologists on character education, Martin Seligman and the late Chris Peterson, and was developed with Angela Duckworth, best known for her research on grit. 

According to Tough, what is useful about these report cards is not that they identify the seven most essential non-cognitive skills. “One could make a reasonable case for excluding some skills and including others.” To him, what is most helpful is that they “start a conversation between teachers, parents, and students” about these skills. He argues that because these reports assess students on multiple aspects (each strength is scored according to how frequently a number of observable behaviors occur), a child is often strong in some of these aspects and weak in others. “So, you can tell a child: ‘You’re great at optimism. Let’s talk about how you can improve at self-control.’ This makes kids want to have these conversations,” says Tough with palpable enthusiasm. 

Tough was far less sanguine about using the report card for accountability purposes. While he points out that “all of our incentives are on the cognitive side of education,” he warns that “this should not be another thing for which we hold teachers accountable.” Instead, Tough argues, “we should change the way we think about accountability.” First, he suggests, we should change how we evaluate schools to focus more on students’ skills rather than on their knowledge. Second, we should continue to monitor the long-term effects of socio-emotional skills and make decisions about school accountability based on those outcomes, which are the ones we ultimately care about.

By the end of my interview, I was ready to convert others, but I had one more question: what are we missing? Since Tough had anticipated the discussion on charter schools and socio-emotional skills, I thought it could not hurt to pick his brain on the next big trend. Tough did not disappoint. “Environments,” he said, with the look of someone who had already given this question some serious thought. “In education, we have conversations about skills, but we actually know a great deal about how adverse environments affect children. We do not think enough about the environments where children are learning every day and how we can change these environments to help them learn more.” 

As always, Tough proves to be at the frontier of education. Research in neuroscience, clinical psychology, and economics has for decades documented the importance of “toxic stress” environments during childhood on long-term outcomes. This research is gaining momentum as new experimental evidence has emerged in recent years. Perhaps, I wondered, I am witnessing the beginning of Tough’s next groundbreaking book.

Alejandro J. Ganimian is a doctoral student in quantitative policy analysis in education at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and a doctoral fellow in the multidisciplinary program in inequality and social policy at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government. 

Themes
Life Skills, Teachers

Join the Discussion

220 comments
Charles's picture
Charles
http://www.kd10shoes.us.com/ KD 10 http://www.pandoras.org.uk/ Pandora Jewelry http://www.adidasnmdofficial.us.com/ Adidas NMD http://www.ralphlaurenpoloshirtsoutlet.org.uk/ Ralph Lauren Polo http://www.kyrie3shoes.us.com/ Kyrie 3 http://www.valentinos.us.com/ Valentino Shoes http://www.timberlandbootsofficial.us.com/ Timberland Boots For Women http://www.timberlandbootsformen.com.co/ Timberland Boots For Women http://www.cgooseparkaoutlet.org.uk/ Canada Goose parka http://www.kyrie4.com.co/ Kyrie 4 http://www.ralphlauren-uk.me.uk/ Ralph Lauren UK http://www.yeezysboost350v2.us.com/ Adidas Yeezy http://www.ralphlaurenoutletpoloonline.us.com/ Ralph Lauren Outlet Online http://www.ralphlaurenpolo-outlet.org.uk/ Ralph Lauren Outlet http://www.nmdadidas.com.co/ NMD Adidas http://www.northfacesjackets.us.com/ North Face Jackets http://www.pandorabraceletuk.org.uk/ Pandora Bracelet UK http://www.vansoutlet-store.us.com/ Vans Shoes http://www.coachoutletonlinehandbags.us.com/ Coach Outlet Online http://www.pandoraringsofficial.us.com/ Pandora Rings Official Site http://www.kd10.com.co/ KD 10 Shoes http://www.uggbootsoutletsale.org.uk/ Ugg Boots http://www.pandorarings.us.com/ Pandora Rings http://www.northfaceoutletoff.us.com/ North Face Outlet http://www.kyrie3.com.co/ Nike Kyrie 3 http://www.pandorajewelryofficialsite.us.com/ Pandora Jewelry http://www.moncleroutletjackets.org.uk/ Moncler Outlet http://www.toryburchoutletinc.us.com/ Tory Burch Outlet Online http://www.officialpandorajewelry.us.com/ Pandora Jewelry 70% off Clearance http://www.michaelkorsoutletofficial.in.net/ Michael Kors Outlet http://www.jamesharden-shoes.us.com/ Harden vol 1 http://www.jimmychoooutletshoes.us.com/ Jimmy Choo Shoes Outlet
reply - Jan 14, 2018
Fyodoroneno's picture
Fyodoroneno
grant writing services professional [url=http://cialisuna.com/]buy cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisuna.com/">generic cialis online</a> business plan help vancouver
reply - Jan 08, 2018
Igorioneno's picture
Igorioneno
cialis online arizona [url=http://cialisjqp.com/]cialis cheap[/url] <a href="http://cialisjqp.com/">generic cialis</a>buying cialis in finland [url=http://cialisnji.com/]generic cialis online[/url] <a href="http://cialisnji.com/">cialis online</a>gem visa cash advance [url=http://soloadvance.com/]payday loans[/url] <a href="http://soloadvance.com/">payday loans</a>
reply - Jan 08, 2018
Igorioneno's picture
Igorioneno
cialis soft meilleur prix [url=http://cialisjqp.com/]cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisjqp.com/">cheap cialis</a>i recommend cialis shop [url=http://cialisnji.com/]cialis online[/url] <a href="http://cialisnji.com/">cialis online</a>payday loan fax pay stub [url=http://soloadvance.com/] cash advance[/url] <a href="http://soloadvance.com/"> pay day loans</a>
reply - Jan 07, 2018
Igorioneno's picture
Igorioneno
acheter cialis cialis [url=http://cialisjqp.com/]cialis cheap[/url] <a href="http://cialisjqp.com/">cialis cheap</a>i recommend cheap price cialis [url=http://cialisnji.com/]cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisnji.com/">cialis online</a>bad credit unsecured loans no guarantor needed [url=http://soloadvance.com/] pay day loans[/url] <a href="http://soloadvance.com/"> payday loans online</a>
reply - Jan 06, 2018
Lyubavaoneno's picture
Lyubavaoneno
can i take viagra im 21 [url=http://viagrahighas.com/]buy viagra online[/url] <a href="http://viagrahighas.com/">buy viagra</a> cual es mejor cialis o viagra
reply - Jan 06, 2018
Tatiyanaoneno's picture
Tatiyanaoneno
40mg cialis is safe [url=http://cialisonlifast.com/]buy cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisonlifast.com/">cialis online</a> good dosage of cialis
reply - Jan 06, 2018
Igorioneno's picture
Igorioneno
acheter cialis cialis [url=http://cialisjqp.com/]generic cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisjqp.com/">cheap cialis</a>es cialis mejor [url=http://cialisnji.com/]generic cialis online[/url] <a href="http://cialisnji.com/">cialis online</a>best payday loans lowest fees [url=http://soloadvance.com/] personal loans[/url] <a href="http://soloadvance.com/"> cash advance</a>
reply - Jan 05, 2018
Witaoneno's picture
Witaoneno
viagra to buy in delhi [url=http://viagrapillskj.com/]generic viagra online[/url] <a href="http://viagrapillskj.com/">cheap viagra</a> ever best viagra tablets
reply - Nov 24, 2017
Alfredoneno's picture
Alfredoneno
we choice where to buy cialis [url=http://cialisorderas.com/]generic cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisorderas.com/">cialis</a> valuti il farmaco cialis
reply - Nov 24, 2017
Zabalkanskijoneno's picture
Zabalkanskijoneno
cialis angels [url=http://cialisgoodss.com/]generic cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialisgoodss.com/">buy cialis</a> cialis causes me headache
reply - Nov 23, 2017
Maryaoneno's picture
Maryaoneno
buy viagra angeles city [url=http://viagrawscheap.com/]viagra cheap[/url] <a href="http://viagrawscheap.com/">cheap viagra</a> can i buy viagra in india
reply - Nov 23, 2017
Snezhanaoneno's picture
Snezhanaoneno
fast viagra uk, [url=http://buyviagralkq.com/]buy chaep viagra[/url] <a href="http://buyviagralkq.com/">buy viagra</a> can a 23 year old take viagra
reply - Nov 21, 2017
Olegoneno's picture
Olegoneno
legal order viagra online [url=http://viagraonlinelka.com/]purchase viagra[/url] <a href="http://viagraonlinelka.com/">online viagra</a> viagra disfuncion erectil
reply - Nov 16, 2017
Danilaoneno's picture
Danilaoneno
cialis sin prescripcio <a href=http://cialisonlinefas.com/>cialis</a> <a href="http://cialisonlinefas.com/">buy cialis</a> prix boite cialis 5mg
reply - Nov 13, 2017
Sokowaoneno's picture
Sokowaoneno
recommended site viagra 10 mg [url=http://viagragenericvas.com/]buy viagra[/url] <a href="http://viagragenericvas.com/">generic viagra online</a> click here fast viagra
reply - Nov 10, 2017
Wadimoneno's picture
Wadimoneno
follow link best online viagra http://viagralkp.com/ - buy viagra <a href="http://viagralkp.com/">viagra cheap</a> only today viagra china
reply - Nov 10, 2017
Sokowaoneno's picture
Sokowaoneno
viagra achat en ligne <a href=http://viagragenericvas.com/>buy viagra online</a> <a href="http://viagragenericvas.com/">viagra cheap</a> compra de viagra de
reply - Nov 10, 2017
Osmininaoneno's picture
Osmininaoneno
compra viagra en sevill <a href=http://viagrahsk.com/>buy generic viagra</a> <a href="http://viagrahsk.com/">buy viagra</a> viagra ucinky
reply - Nov 08, 2017
Alaoneno's picture
Alaoneno
takeing 2 cialis 20mg <a href=http://cialisbva.com/>cialis cheap</a> <a href="http://cialisbva.com/">cialis cheap</a> cialis rezeptfrei online
reply - Nov 07, 2017
Alaoneno's picture
Alaoneno
get cialis fast shipping <a href=http://cialisbva.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cialisbva.com/">cialis</a> are there generic cialis
reply - Nov 07, 2017
Vidmanoneno's picture
Vidmanoneno
just try! generic cialis sale <a href=http://cialisknz.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://cialisknz.com/">buy cialis</a> cialis online for canadian
reply - Oct 26, 2017
Tomaoneno's picture
Tomaoneno
good choice pill price viagra http://viagrakjs.com/ - viagra generic <a href="http://viagrakjs.com/">cheap viagra</a> viagra antibiotika
reply - Oct 25, 2017
Tomaoneno's picture
Tomaoneno
viagra e cialis insieme http://viagrakjs.com/ - viagra generic <a href="http://viagrakjs.com/">viagra cheap</a> viagra para hombres jovene
reply - Oct 25, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
cialis complaints <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>cialis canada</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">canadian cialis</a> precios cialis baratos
reply - Oct 14, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
cialis 40mg jelly <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>canadian cialis</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">cialis canada</a> cialis overdosage
reply - Oct 12, 2017
Gerhaoneno's picture
Gerhaoneno
cialis mercado libre <a href=http://buycheapkcialis.com/>cialis</a> <a href="http://buycheapkcialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> achat cialis 5mg professionnel
reply - Oct 08, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
cvs price for 20 mg of cialis <a href=http://cialiskkcanada.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">buy cialis online</a> cialis 40 mg bestellen
reply - Oct 07, 2017
Gerhaoneno's picture
Gerhaoneno
best online cialis canada <a href=http://buycheapkcialis.com/>cialis</a> <a href="http://buycheapkcialis.com/">generic cialis online</a> acquista cialis once a day
reply - Oct 07, 2017
Volodoneno's picture
Volodoneno
cialis us pharmancy [url=http://cialiskkcanada.com/]generic cialis[/url] <a href="http://cialiskkcanada.com/">cialis online</a> we like it generic cialis usa
reply - Oct 06, 2017
Gerfdoneno's picture
Gerfdoneno
viagra users age <a href=http://viagracheappbgs.com/>viagra online</a> <a href="http://viagracheappbgs.com/">buy viagra</a> original viagra
reply - Oct 06, 2017
Gerfdoneno's picture
Gerfdoneno
take viagra best results <a href=http://viagracheappbgs.com/>viagra generic</a> <a href="http://viagracheappbgs.com/">buy viagra online</a> viagra prices in bangalore
reply - Oct 05, 2017
Gerfdoneno's picture
Gerfdoneno
viagra premature ejeculation <a href=http://viagracheappbgs.com/>buy viagra online</a> <a href="http://viagracheappbgs.com/">viagra generic</a> hard get prescription viagra
reply - Oct 04, 2017
BrianKiz's picture
BrianKiz
<a href=http://www.napabvi.com/banner/images/slide.php?gt=45/>Cialis Deutschland Paypal</a> Use ranking systems cautiously in a keep industry. These ranking solutions can be untrustworthy during this period, so you could end up losing a lot of money when you count only upon them. Instead of utilizing them as being a manual, utilize them a method of secondary information and component the status into the selections having a grain of sea salt. <a href=http://www.tangkasroyal.com/Admin/player.asp?pl=94-Levitra-Precio-Levitra-Generico-Precio-Mexico-Levitra-Precio-Farmacias-Del-Ahorro>Levitra Precio</a> Joint disease can occasionally cause skin breakouts in the arthritic locations on your system or on your deal with. If it is the case, you can get conceal and also other constitute to cover these skin breakouts. Numerous joint disease victims think that they should avoid make up, which happens to be not correct. <a href=http://www.ndlehighvalley.org/images/footer.asp?h=114>Kamagra Oral Jelly Singapore</a> To help make the ideal cup of joe, you require recently terrain espresso. Espresso, like many other meals, can drop its types and also other unique qualities when subjected to air flow, lighting, and heat. Food market ordered terrain gourmet coffee is not going to flavor just like whole, roasted espresso legumes that you just grind your self. <a href=http://www.finnodata.com/styles/banner.php?rs=Lovegra-Test,Viagra-Deutschland-Paypal,Viagra-Kaufen-Holland-42/>Lovegra Test</a>
reply - Oct 03, 2017
Herbertbag's picture
Herbertbag
<a href=http://www.strandbyhavn.dk/billeder/joll.php?my=138>Viagra Salg</a> The ideal websites interact a great deal of information in a modest amount of phrases. When you are lengthy-winded, individuals will effortlessly become bored and locate another web site which is far more succinct. Be sure any content articles are pertinent and straightforward - magazines make use of an eighth class looking at degree, the most frequent literacy level. <a href=http://www.ybcom.nl/wp-includes/banner.php?orderby=50-Cialis-Bestellen-Nederland,Cialis-Kopen-In-Duitsland,Cialis-Prijs-Apotheek>Cialis Bestellen Nederland</a> Search for on the internet information about different wines. Locate a wine dialogue discussion board and study the comments till you really feel assured adequate to add your own personal concepts. In case you are unfamiliar with international wines, this can be a great spot to get information. You are able to obtain enough information to try several wines you would not or else have regarded as. <a href=http://www.clip-tv.at/wp-admin/user/class.php?p=46>Cialis Deutschland Preise</a> Many initial-time house consumers make the dire error of neglecting to spending budget beyond the preliminary deposit. In most cases, relocating and shutting down charges can make up up to ten percent of your respective overall amount borrowed. Be well prepared by requesting an estimated estimation of charges from the home loan broker or loan company. <a href=http://amandaamorim.adv.br/fullslider/slider/assets/return.php?gb1=36>Lovegra Online</a>
reply - Oct 03, 2017
Verneoneno's picture
Verneoneno
le viagra generiqu http://canadianviagrats.com/ - viagra canada <a href="http://canadianviagrats.com/">viagra canada</a> prescription viagra nz
reply - Oct 01, 2017
Nerkooneno's picture
Nerkooneno
how much viagra is safe <a href=http://viagragenericsj.com/>buy cheap viagra</a> <a href="http://viagragenericsj.com/">viagra online</a> cialis levitra viagra vs vs
reply - Oct 01, 2017
Voldemoneno's picture
Voldemoneno
get best results cialis <a href=http://buycialishgonline.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://buycialishgonline.com/">cialis</a> we like it purchase cialis
reply - Sep 30, 2017
Revebaoneno's picture
Revebaoneno
viagra pa recept <a href=http://cheaphgviagra.com/>buy viagra</a> <a href="http://cheaphgviagra.com/">viagra coupon</a> viagra levitra di
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Bailooneno's picture
Bailooneno
achat de cialis non generique <a href=http://cialischeapoks.com/>buy cialis online</a> <a href="http://cialischeapoks.com/">buy cialis</a> cialis da 100 mg
reply - Sep 27, 2017
Vomironeno's picture
Vomironeno
viagra cheap viagra online <a href=http://viagrabuygenzx.com/>buy cheap viagra</a> <a href="http://viagrabuygenzx.com/">buy viagra</a> viagra ciales en espana
reply - Sep 26, 2017
Gelesoneno's picture
Gelesoneno
generic cialis sublingual us <a href=http://cheapjicialis.com/>buy cialis</a> <a href="http://cheapjicialis.com/">cialis coupon</a> online cialis 5mg
reply - Sep 25, 2017
Alenaoneno's picture
Alenaoneno
le meilleur prix cialis pilule <a href=http://buycialiskj.com/>generic cialis</a> <a href="http://buycialiskj.com/">cialis coupon</a> compare prices cialis uk
reply - Sep 25, 2017
Goloaoneno's picture
Goloaoneno
cialis ricetta <a href=http://canadianfdcialis.com/>cialis online</a> <a href="http://canadianfdcialis.com/">buy cialis online</a> non-prescription cialis
reply - Sep 23, 2017
Moisesoneno's picture
Moisesoneno
viagra buy online in pakistan <a href=http://buycxviagra.com/>viagra</a> <a href="http://buycxviagra.com/">order viagra</a> viagra le generique
reply - Sep 22, 2017
Fedyaoneno's picture
Fedyaoneno
viagra se vende sin receta http://viagralpo.com/ - viagra <a href="http://viagralpo.com/">viagra canada</a> viagra sellers in dubai
reply - Sep 20, 2017
Jkosoneno's picture
Jkosoneno
60 mg cialis online http://cialisolas.com/ - cialis price <a href="http://cialisolas.com/">cialis coupon</a> cialis blindness
reply - Sep 20, 2017
ashokdkrana's picture
ashokdkrana
ShiftingSolutions.in offers Free Quotes of Registered Movers and Packers Bangalore (Bengaluru). Compare to save money and select the best. http://www.erq.io/CZn7j
reply - Sep 16, 2017
Solooneno's picture
Solooneno
installment loan increase credit score http://soloadvance.com/ - personal loans <a href="http://soloadvance.com/"> personal loans</a> personal loans in wichita ks
reply - Sep 15, 2017
Olegoneno's picture
Olegoneno
best cash advance KC 64120 http://fastloansolo.com/ - pay day loans <a href="http://fastloansolo.com/"> pay day loans</a> personal loans williamston nc
reply - Sep 15, 2017

Pages

X